Real Madrid got a controversial victory last match, with refereeing that has left many doubts and divided opinions. During extra time, referee Munuera Montero's decision caused great controversy and didn't go unnoticed. The controversy focuses on two key plays: one by Antonio Rüdiger and a similar one by Koundé in a recent match.
Rüdiger's Key Play
In the 104th minute, with the score 2-2, Real Madrid was involved in a controversial play. Rüdiger blocked a ball with his hand inside the area, an action that could well have been penalized with a penalty shot.
However, the referee didn't call it at all and the most striking aspect of the play was the lack of a video replay. Even though VAR had the ability to review the play, no image was shown, nor were any details of the decision offered.
The controversy grew because, in similar cases like Koundé's, technology and replays were used to clarify the situation. However, in this case, VAR didn't provide the replay of Rüdiger's handball, leaving the doubt in the air.
The Possible Lack of Transparency
The referee, Munuera Montero, argued that the play had been invalidated due to an alleged offside by Bamba, a Celta player. According to the referee, the offside at the start of the play invalidated any subsequent action, like Rüdiger's handball. However, the problem here is that the semi-automatic offside image wasn't shown, which has raised suspicions about the lack of transparency.
In situations like this, where VAR plays an essential role, fans and journalists have been surprised by the lack of clarity in resolving the play. Celta's followers, as well as many neutrals, have complained that the offside image wasn't shown and have demanded more transparency in the process.
Comparison with the Koundé Case
The situation becomes even more controversial when compared to what happened recently with Koundé. In that match, the Barcelona player had a goal disallowed for a millimetric position, instantly clarified with technology. The difference with Rüdiger's case is enormous, as the VAR images that could clarify whether he was offside weren't shown.
Many are wondering why, in this case, VAR hasn't shown the replay that would clarify the situation. "Where's the offside picture?" fans have asked. They believe they deserved a chance for the penalty to be called, and the goal could have been validated.