The debate over Real Madrid's right-back position is more alive than ever. Xabi Alonso has a decision on the table that will shape the team's immediate future. It's about trusting Trent Alexander-Arnold or opting for captain Dani Carvajal.
The Englishman arrived at Santiago Bernabéu with the label of a top-tier signing, but his performances haven't managed to convince either the coaching staff or the demanding white fans.
In his LaLiga debut, his performance was once again called into question. This time, one of the most influential journalists among Madridists, Tomás Roncero, delivered a forceful message that has ignited the debate.
Roncero doesn't hold back
"Trent doesn't deserve to be a starter," Tomás Roncero emphasizes regarding the English right-back's situation. His match wasn't up to par. He left the impression that he still hasn't understood what it means to defend Real Madrid's badge.
What has made the former Liverpool player's starting spot even more complicated is Dani Carvajal's return. The white captain returned to the starting eleven after 318 days without playing in the league following the serious injury he suffered against Villarreal.
His return was celebrated as a triumph in itself and, most importantly, it restored confidence to the white defense. He then started in Oviedo in what is interpreted as a serious warning from Xabi Alonso to the English international.
"He either changes his mindset or he'll have to go to the bench." That's Roncero's verdict on SER regarding the attitude Trent must show if he wants to win the spot over Carvajal.
For the journalist, it's not just a matter of technical quality. It's also about commitment, dedication, and leadership in a position that has historically been key at Real Madrid.
Carvajal's role as captain
Trent won't have it easy. His competition is Dani Carvajal who, after 13 seasons at the club and six Champions League titles, faces the challenge of wearing the captain's armband.
This new role has multiplied his influence in the locker room and his importance on the field.
"Carvajal gives the team an energy the Englishman can't provide," Roncero comments on how the team's face changes when the captain is on the field. With his entry, Madrid regained verticality, character, and defensive solidity, which created a clear contrast with Alexander-Arnold's performance.
Xabi Alonso, between construction and destruction
Xabi Alonso values Trent's ability to build up play, especially at Bernabéu, where the team has possession and dominates.
However, when Real Madrid plays away, more defensive precautions must be taken, and the Englishman doesn't offer Carvajal's guarantees.
The white coach knows he'll have to make tough decisions. Everything suggests the Englishman could be relegated to the bench if he doesn't immediately raise his level. Or he could turn Trent into a "home player, reserved for matches at Bernabéu."
Roncero's message is clear. Arnold must change his mentality if he doesn't want to see Carvajal consolidate himself as the owner of Real Madrid's right-back position.